Discussion in Illegal Spots started by Moofasa, Feb 12, 2011
is this illegal? I think its a ledge spot. it has only one way to get there.
If the absolute only way to get there is across that narrow beam, then I'd be really tempted to say it's illegal. I don't really care for lila_panic maps though so I don't even have that one. Someone else will have to test it out and check.
thats the only way to get over there. So I'd say its illegal
MOMO DONT SPAM
I would have to test it, i think you can jump from the roof if you b-hoped.
I tested that location and you can reach it from the railing which extends over the side, or off the roof. I was successful after a few attempts with 4 people firing.. I did have a few distraction assistance however..
Yeah, that spot is crazy. I tried to jump from the roof but I didn't get too far, only to the middle of that narrow wooden board. Can't double/triple stack underneath unless super boost (not sure how its done). I'd say illegal too.
Even if you can bunny-hop to a spot, that doesn't make it legal. You need to consider how small the number of people is that can actually pull it off, let alone while being shot at.
Why not? There are some spots that are very difficult for some people to get to that are still legal... I didn't realize we were deciding the legality of spots based on how many people know how to get to them. Using this logic we need to make all secret rooms in the new version of wtfh4x illegal as well because only a tiny amount of people know how to get to them...
What does that have to do with the spot being an illegal ledge spot? Bunny hopping or not, the only method of access is a narrow beam, which by definition makes it a ledge spot. If that spot is made legal, then other currently illegal ledges would need to be reviewed as well due to their similarity.
Ok umm so get there via narrow beam or jump to it via bonny hop... 2 ways to get to the spot. Or am i missing something.
Just take away the whole Bhop thing out of your mind, because the majority of people whom play ZM don't know/can't bhop. So then there is only one way to get to it: by the narrow wooden beam, which I believe is classified as a 'ledge'.
Once again, i dont care how many people can bhop, if you can bhop to the spot that means TWO entries. Period, end of discussion. We base the decision on the number of entry points not their difficulty. If we start making spots illegal based on difficulty half of every damn map would be illegal.
actually there are multiple ways to get there
2. BHOP w/ zombies mass rushing (yes its possible)
3. BOOST JUMP
4*. LONG JUMP - not sure if this is possible, looks possible from the picture but i may be mistaken.
Here's another spot... you can jump over the fence, no problem, its the crouching under the crane clamp to get back there that makes it illegal imho...
when typing !Illegal none of these spots show up :/.
4 more spots
Both Same Crouch Spot
The documented spots have been made official: http://www.plaguefest.com/harvey/illegalspots/zm_lila_panic_f3_v3.html
Thanks to all that participated.
Separate names with a comma.